Versions Compared


  • This line was added.
  • This line was removed.
  • Formatting was changed.


  • Cons
    • Might have more restrictions on how the framework should be. OSGI etc (pablaasmo).
    • Their projects websites are crap and I find them hard to find (vtintillier)
    • If our goal is not to re-unite with Hudson, it's unlikely that Jenkins will be accepted (kutzi)
    • The eclipse IP process makes it very hard for occasional contributors. Many will just give up. (magnayn)
      • For the contributor it's simply a bugzilla and a short statement that the contributor has the right to donate the code. Is that so hard? (jutzig)
    • Bugzilla. Ick. (abayer)
    • Compared with ASF, more decisions in Eclipse depend on the Board and the Eclipse Staff.  The bylaws are 24 pages (see here and the rest of the Governance Documents).  As a specific, possibly infrequent, decision, see this comment from the Foundation on community reactions to the donation (pelegri)